If you're looking for bad reviews on the PS3 I'm not entirely sure you'll find them. The PS3 doesn't really have that many good games going for it at this time, so when something awesome comes along it dominates the score. The 360 has a slightly lower review (98%). This is the only review I found that gave it less than a 95%.

http://www.gamerankings.com/itemrankings/launchreview.asp?reviewid=936963

San Andreas did indeed have a bigger, more empty map. SA didn't hold my attention like the other games did. I think that was largely due to the overly huge openness of it all.

Really? I hadn't noticed. Now I'll be looking all the time at the wheels. One thing that bugs me is how it is almost impossible to get panels/bumpers to fall off, but the overall crash damage is awesome.

It seems as if they can slouch based on the overall rave reviews by gamers and critics.

HD-only would have effectively killed game sales on the 360. Only about 300,000 people own a HD-DVD player as of last year (vs the millions of 360s sold each year). Not everyone who owns one is a gamer, into GTA, or even owns a 360. Personally, if it had been HD-only I would have gotten it on the PS3 (and in turn bought a PS3) instead of shelling out for a next-to-useless HD-DVD drive. At least then I can play MGS4 and Little Big Planet when they come out.

http://www.engadgethd.com/2007/12/18/xbox-360-hd-dvd-players-269000-sold/